Artificial AI states this: Ahh — this tells me exactly what’s happening. You’re being funneled into the 1099‑R workflow, which means TurboTax thinks you converted money, not that you recharacteriz...
See more...
Artificial AI states this: Ahh — this tells me exactly what’s happening. You’re being funneled into the 1099‑R workflow, which means TurboTax thinks you converted money, not that you recharacterized a contribution. That’s why you’re not seeing any of the nondeductible‑IRA questions. And that mismatch is what creates the phantom “penalty” warning in Deductions & Credits even though the 1099‑R section says “Good news, no penalty.” Let’s fix the root cause cleanly. 🎯 What’s going wrong A recharacterization should be entered in the Traditional IRA contribution section, not the 1099‑R section. But TurboTax only asks about recharacterization before you enter any 1099‑R. Once you enter a 1099‑R, TurboTax assumes: You did a conversion, not a recharacterization It skips the nondeductible contribution logic It skips Form 8606 Part I It warns about excess contributions or penalties in Deductions & Credits This is exactly the pattern you’re describing. 🛠️ How to fix it (step‑by‑step) You’ll need to delete the 1099‑R first, then re‑enter the contribution correctly. 1. Delete the 1099‑R Go to: Wages & Income → IRA, 401(k), Pension → Review → Delete the 1099‑R A recharacterization does not generate a 1099‑R in the same tax year. (You get it next January.) 2. Now go to the Traditional IRA contribution section Deductions & Credits → Retirement & Investments → Traditional IRA Contributions Choose Your Wife. Answer: YES she contributed to a Traditional IRA Enter the amount (e.g., 6,500) Now TurboTax will ask: “Did you recharacterize this contribution?” This is the screen you were missing. Select YES. Enter: The amount recharacterized Any earnings/losses (from the custodian letter) 3. TurboTax will then say: “Your IRA contribution is not deductible.” This is correct for a backdoor Roth. This is how TurboTax marks it as nondeductible and puts it on Form 8606. 4. Check the warning in Deductions & Credits again It should now disappear because TurboTax no longer thinks you made: an excess Roth contribution a deductible Traditional IRA contribution a taxable conversion 🧪 If you want, I can pinpoint the exact screen causing the penalty Just tell me which of these you see in Deductions & Credits: “You have an excess Roth IRA contribution” “Your IRA contribution is not deductible” “You may owe a penalty on your IRA contribution” “You contributed more than allowed to a Roth IRA” Each one maps to a different mis‑entry, and I can walk you straight to the fix. You’re very close — this is just a sequencing issue, not a real tax problem. Please validate!