I took a cash-out refinance in 2020 and used part of the cash out for home improvement (new doors). Because the loan processing took longer than originally scheduled I needed to borrow the money to pay for the doors and then pay the person back when the refinance came through later.
Would I still be able to deduct the interest on the portion used for home improvement under these circumstances?
You'll need to sign in or create an account to connect with an expert.
Yes. However, remember that on the portion of the Cash Out used to substantially improve your home. So you will need to calculate the amount that is strictly related to buying, building or substantially improving your home. The interest on any portion that was used for any other reason is not tax deductible.
You can deduct interest on acquisition debt. Acquisition debt is debt that was incurred to buy, build, or substantially improve your home.
So one issue is, are new doors a "substantial improvement." Here is the IRS instruction.
Substantial improvement.
An improvement is substantial if it:
Adds to the value of your home,
Prolongs your home's useful life, or
Adapts your home to new uses.
Repairs that maintain your home in good condition, such as repainting your home, aren't substantial improvements. However, if you paint your home as part of a renovation that substantially improves your qualified home, you can include the painting costs in the cost of the improvements.
The second issue is timing. Generally speaking, you can count expenses you paid before the loan came through if the loan is "made" (approved and paid out) within 90 days after the completion of the work. If the loan was applied for before the end of 90 days but not approved until after the 90 days, it will usually be acceptable if audited.
What's the time limit by which I would have to use the cash amount in qualified home improvement? Say I receive 100K from cash out refinance on July 1, 2020. Within how many days do I have to use up 100K for qualified home improvement?
2 years (730 days). But the mortgage interest is not qualified acquisition debt until actually spent on improvements, and you need to keep track.
@Opus 17 : thanks for the clarification. Yes, I understood that I can only consider mortgage interest of 100K deductible only after 100K (or more) is spent on home improvements.
A bit more complex scenario: what happens if trace of 100K is not direct? i.e. In 2020, I got cashout, and used up 100K in another investment (e.g. rental property), and in July 2021, I make home improvement of 100K from my own savings. Would the 100K be considered as part of acquisition debt starting July 2021?
It depends on how you have elected to treat that interest in the meantime. If you can meet the tracing requirements, you have the option of treating that $100,000 of interest as an investment expense on your schedule E, and you could do that from the day you purchased the rental property. That does not require you to itemize your deductions on schedule A and is not limited by any of the schedule A limitations. However, once you decide that that mortgage was used for an investment, you are stuck with that choice and you can’t change the treatment of the debt to treat it as a home acquisition debt once you make the improvements to your personal home.
I can’t tell you whether it would be more to your advantage to treat the debt as an investment expense or a personal expense. If you have not filed your 2020 tax return you can decide when you file whether to treat the refinance as partly investment interest. If you already filed a tax return for 2020 and you treated the $100,000 of equity debt as an investment expense on schedule E and you now regret that and want to change to treat it as a personal mortgage on schedule A, you must file an amended return to change the status for May 17. (In this case, changing your choice means removing the loan as an investment expense but not adding it yet as a personal mortgage deduction because it does not yet qualify.)
Hi, I would like to follow up on this with a related question: I am currently starting with a renovation and want to do a cash out refinance to pay for it. So I'll likely do the cash out refi in Nov'21 but the vast amount of expenses will occur through '22. If I understand you correctly as long as I say keep the money on a separate account and track what is spend when, i can deduct mortgage interest from taxes. So for 2022 that would make my tax filing a bit difficult since I will only have spend the whole cash out part at the end of the year. Example: if I spend half of the amount on January 1st I can deduct the interest for that half for the whole year, if I spend the rest at the end of June I can deduct interest for that for only half the year. For 2023 (when everything is spend) I can simply deduct all interest. Did I understand that correctly? Also, could you point me to the source of the 2 years? irs publication 936 sounded like only expenses occurred prior to refi count as acquisition debt. Thanks for clarifying this.
For 2022, you can use the simplified method to determine the amount of qualified mortgage interest you paid. You were determined the total amount and acquisition debt amount as of January 1 and December 31 and then average to get the deductible amount of interest. For example, suppose you borrowed $200,000, of which $50,000 was acquisition debt. On January 1, 75% of your interest as qualified.You were determined the total amount and acquisition debt amount as of January 1 and December 31 and then average to get the deductible amount of interest.
For example, suppose you borrowed $200,000, of which $150,000 was acquisition debt. On January 1, 75% of your interest was qualified. During 2022 you paid $30,000 for improvements. As of December 31, your total loan balance was $198,000 (because you paid some against the principle) and your acquisition debt was $180,000, making 91% of your interest qualified. Averaged together, you can deduct 83% of your mortgage interest for the year.
As far as the two-year rule, I did not find it in black-and-white in publication 936, but the situation is murky. The tax law only says that interest on qualified acquisition debt may be deducted, and that qualified acquisition debt includes debt he used to buy, build, or substantially improve the home.
The IRS creates regulations that expand upon the law and explain how the law is to be followed, but if the regulations disagree with the law, the law must prevail. I could not find the specific regulation for this situation, but I may not have looked long enough.
Then the IRS creates publications that explain the regulations in simple language. There are several cases where the publication ignores or over simplifies certain aspects of the tax law, and some things that are allowed by the law or not included in the publications. Publication 936 has a statement under the heading of “debt that may qualify later“ which says that if you take a loan out before making the renovations, you can only count as qualified acquisition debt, reservations made in the two years before the loan. That makes absolutely no sense to me, and it ignores the plain language of the law, which says that acquisition debt includes the cost of renovations. The language in the publication is a misinterpretation or simple mistake. Even if not, it contradicts the law in an important common sense way— how can you pay for a renovation without taking out the loan first, but the loan doesn’t qualify if you take it out first. that just feels a commonsense test and I don’t believe that a court would hold it was a valid interpretation of the plain language of the law.
There is a separate provision that if you borrow money to construct your house, it can count as your residence for the interest deduction as long as you finish the house within two years.
Putting all that together, I think it is reasonable to conclude that if you borrow money to pay for a renovation, you can count those renovations as qualified acquisition costs as long as you complete them with a reasonable time after taking out the loan. And since two years is used in other cases covered by the law, it seems reasonable to use it here too.
Still have questions?
Make a postAsk questions and learn more about your taxes and finances.
moorejohn
New Member
taxamedmed
Level 3
tp320580
New Member
futurestrader39
Level 3
jlrodriguez2480
New Member
Did the information on this page answer your question?
You have clicked a link to a site outside of the TurboTax Community. By clicking "Continue", you will leave the Community and be taken to that site instead.