You'll need to sign in or create an account to connect with an expert.
It is a gray area. Usually, the income of an inmate is from the penal system. Even a halfway house or work release is still part of that system. This bulletin does not address house arrest, but it does go into great detail about what is included in the penal system.
Although an individual may be allowed to participate in a work release program, those individuals are still confined to the penal institution and must return to the penal institution when not performing services. Although the work performed by those individuals is not performed at the penal institution itself, it is performed while the individual is an inmate at a penal institution. Neither section 32(c)(2)(B)(iv) of the Code nor its legislative history suggests that the place where the work is performed is relevant to a determination of whether the services are provided while the individual is an inmate at a penal institution. Thus, any payments received by the inmate while performing services in a work release program are amounts received while the individual is an inmate at a penal institution. Those amounts are excluded from the definition of earned income under section 32(c)(2)(B)(iv) of the Code.
With respect to individuals transferred to a halfway house, those individuals have not been released from their sentences, can be returned to the prison facility, and are usually required to perform services. Although these individuals are not confined to a prison, jail, or penitentiary, they are confined to the halfway house for the remainder of their sentence. Thus, a halfway house falls within the general definition of a penal institution. Accordingly, any amounts received for services performed by an inmate while at a halfway house are amounts received for services performed while at a penal institution. Those amounts are excluded from the definition of earned income under section 32(c)(2)(B)(iv) of the Code.
Therefore he should admend his tax return & unclaim those credits I assume? Will turbo tax walk him through this process since he filed with tt? And lastly is it legal or are you allowed to unclaim a dependent and someone else claim her?
We have a daughter 6 years of age, she lives with me now but in 2021 she lived with us both the same amount of time, we live a houses away & I've always let him claim her with no problems, until now but I don't want to make things worse.
I guess I'm asking if it's even legal to unclaim a dependent & someone else claim that Said dependent?
Because it was a honest mistake it's very vague about the issue but After reading your letter I do lean towards Home dentintion Is not eligible to claim eic or ctc.
If the return has already been accepted by the IRS, he will need to file an amended return. Yes, TurboTax will walk him through the process of amending his return to remove the dependent. The amended Form 1040-X can be e-filed.
It is perfectly legal for someone to not claim a dependent based on the situation that you described. It is a gray area and not specifically addressed by the IRS.
You will be able to claim your daughter on your return without a problem. His amended return could take up to 16 weeks to be processed. Your return that claims your dependent daughter should be mailed to the IRS. It would probably be rejected if e-filed since your daughter's SSN has already been used as a dependent. This situation will not create any red flags with the IRS.
Still have questions?
Questions are answered within a few hours on average.
Post a Question*Must create login to post
Ask questions and learn more about your taxes and finances.
carolynkisler
New Member
bhsong206
Level 2
winegardens6
New Member
pandam97
Level 1
Iseewhatshappeningheretoo
Returning Member