1251354
Attempting to complete my return, Turbotax suggests I'm not eligible for e-Filing in NJ. The reason listed is:
"When claiming Earned Income Tax Credit, returns with Wages Earned as Household Employee and/or Wages not reported on Form W-2s are ineligible for electronic filing"
The problem is, we are NOT claiming EIC. We have no kids and our AGI is too high. I've checked the 1040 and state forms and none of the EIC information is filled out. I've even tried putting 0s in there too. There is an EIC Worksheet which I've tried deleting and it just returns.
Feels like a Turbotax bug.
Version Info:
wrapper: [phone number removed]
WinPerReleaseEngine: [phone number removed]
WinperFedFormset: [phone number removed]
WinPerTaxSupport: [phone number removed]
You'll need to sign in or create an account to connect with an expert.
Tried removing the NJ portion of the return (File -> remove state return) and re-adding. Same issue.
Tried to call support for help. Here's what I learned:
- They don't have access to the development team. Can't open tickets for them or escalate. While very friendly, my support rep wasn't very technical at all and just assumed I was making a mistake. The troubleshooting was basically "Are you sure you clicked everything correctly?"
- They are forced to close all tickets by the end of the day.
- They wanted to remote into my home PC and access my return data to see the error message I was getting, even though I read it word-for-word over the phone and told them about this post. I declined. Really unsafe and irresponsible for Turbotax to suggest that without an NDA or some other protection.
Pretty shocking this is how enterprise support is being run.
My next step is to purchase a competitive tax program, import my Turbotax return, and see if that also flags the return for the alleged claim of EIC. If I'm able to file through the competitive program, I'll solicit a refund from Intuit.
Been a customer for more than a decade. So disappointed in their support organization, specifically:
- Tickets should never be forced to close within the same day. What universe does Intuit live in that their customers experience problems that all magically are resolved within 24 hours? The whole concept of 'time to resolution' for Intuit's metrics should be discarded then.
- There should be an escalation path to development, even if that's not visible to the end user. Intuit updates Turbotax dozens of times during tax season. Many updates aren't just new forms, but rather fixes in the way the application works. Why is it a stretch to assume that I'm NOT doing anything wrong?
- In an age where identity theft is rampant, to suggest that any of us share our financial returns with individual support representatives is irresponsible. This is by no means the same as an encrypted transmission of the return, through Turbotax, to our government or states. I have no NDAs or other vehicles by which to protect my return data should the Turbotax team handle my return in an inappropriate fashion.
More updates to follow.
As promised, I purchased a competitive tax program. I put in the same information and received the same result with respect to payment due to federal and state. HOWEVER, I was able to e-File successfully without a message that I was allegedly claiming earned income tax credit.
I guess I'll use the competitor going forward. I'll let the forum know if Turbotax is willing to do the right thing and provide a refund.
I've sent an email to Turbotax leadership on Monday. Waiting patiently for a response.
I have sent you a private message, please take a look at that when you can.
Still have questions?
Questions are answered within a few hours on average.
Post a Question*Must create login to post
Ask questions and learn more about your taxes and finances.
cggp
New Member
eobryan0608
Level 1
mihir1
New Member
didideanda1814
New Member
brian-h-bell
New Member