This is likely not an easy question to answer, especially with possibly some missing details, but here goes.
My spouse bought a house a dozen years ago with a first-time homebuyer program from the city that the house is in. The city considered this a "loan" that you do not have to pay back until 30 years, or the house sells, whichever comes first. However, the contract says they own the percentage of equity that they initially contributed. Example figures are:
- Purchase Price: $600,000
- City "loan": $200,000
- City says they have 33.3% equity of this property
For selling the house, let's say we cannot claim any exemptions to the capital gains tax (e.g. no 1031, no primary residence exemption, etc). Let's then say it sells for, as an example, $1,000,000 after all closing costs. How do we calculate capital gains tax with equity sharing? Upon closing, if I understand correctly, the city would get their 33% of funds automatically through escrow (if that matters).
My hope is that we would say that our purchase price was ($600,000 minus $200,000) = $400,000, and sale price is ($1,000,000 minus their 33% equity of $333,333) = $666,667. So the capital gains would be $266,667.
However, my pessimistic mind also says that the IRS doesn't care about equity sharing, and would want the owner (not the equity sharer) on the hook for the original purchase price and sale price. If that's the case, then the capital gains would be $1,000,000 - $600,000 = $400,000 in taxable capital gains.
I'm not sure which is correct. Since this situation is uncommon, it seems to have to be manually entered in Turbo Tax. Thus, we have to know which figures to input. Thanks a lot for any advice.
You'll need to sign in or create an account to connect with an expert.
take the contract to a real estate attorney.
As Mike9241 said, you may need professional help with this, depending on the details.
That said, I assume you paid the city $200,000, essentially paying off the "loan", just like paying off the mortgage. The whole $400,000 capital gain is yours.
It sounds like the 33% equity is just "collateral" and has nothing to do with with sharing the gain.
I'm not a lawyer.
Agreed ... if you paid off the loan at closing then I am of the opinion that it is treated like any other lien on the property ... they never really "owned" any portion of the home however getting an opinion from a local RE attorney may be wise or at least ask the city and/or closing company (they might have seen this before).
Thanks all, for your feedback and help. The steps will be to:
1) find the original contract
2) consult a real estate attorney
Still have questions?
Make a postAsk questions and learn more about your taxes and finances.
Fr8tech
Level 2
CA_Tax_Man
Level 2
chandra-santamon
New Member
stamperhs20
New Member
mstruzak
Level 2
Did the information on this page answer your question?
You have clicked a link to a site outside of the TurboTax Community. By clicking "Continue", you will leave the Community and be taken to that site instead.