You'll need to sign in or create an account to connect with an expert.
@DM26 wrote:I do not believe this is open for discussion and that the IRS requires this election and affirmation to be separately signed and dated by the taxpayer. In fact this is the reason why TurboTax has not allowed e-filing with this statement.
Did you read the posts in the link I provided in my earlier post? The tax professionals posting on that site do not believe that the IRS requires the statement to be signed.
Further, the TurboTax now appears to allow e-filing with the statement for the 2021 tax year.
If TurboTax does in fact allow e-filing 2021 tax returns with the Safe Harbor attached then I am grateful as this has been a long battle. Hopefully others who have e-filed their returns can confirm. For those who have already e-filed I am also curious to know if the statement was signed and uploaded prior to being attached.
In regards to your link as to the “Tax Professionals” statement that the signature is not required, I don’t feel that site is trustworthy. I also have an intuit online account and clicked reply to the same forum. I did not reply but certainly could if I wanted. I am attaching a print screen of this. It appears that forum is no different than this one as most anyone can provide their opinion.
Unfortunately this subject continues to be very ambiguous. Throughout the internet you can find opinions from both sides, I am providing a few stating a signature is required in the links below. I continue to side with the signature requirement and would rather be protected than not.
Links:
The first link may not work since it mistakes a set of numbers to be a phone number and rejects it. Below is a print screen of some of it's content:
Has anyone actually been able to efile with the safe harbor 199A? I got to the end last year before it dis allowed the efile. Pretty sure was AFTER i hit the file now button that it denied the efile.
Does the IRS finalized safe harbor to allow commercial rental real estate to qualify as a business for QBI deduction make the income subject to earned income self-employment tax?
@jbshawaii wrote:
Does the IRS finalized safe harbor to allow commercial rental real estate to qualify as a business for QBI deduction make the income subject to earned income self-employment tax?
No. Rental real estate is never subject to self-employment tax unless the real estate is being held as a rental by a real estate dealer (who sells real estate in the ordinary course of business) or if the owner provides "substantial services" to renters (i.e., operates the rental property similar to a hotel).
So i was just able to efile with the safe harbor (i think) 199a form.
The strange thing is when i checked the forms before filing the safe harbor statement 199a was there.
But that form was not included after i efiled and downloaded the fed and state returns.
But my 1st attempt to efile failed. My agi confirmation requested to confirm my id, because i paper filed last year, was not accepted because i believe my fed return has not been processed. I owed last year and they did cash my check. NY state also lost my returns.
So turbo tax guided me to put in 0 for the agi and that did work. But before i re efiled i checked the forms again and saw the safe harbor form and additional worksheets. So i downloaded that before my 2nd efile attempt. Turbotax now showing Fed return as accepted and state returns now pending.
All had previously been rejected.
Thank you for sharing this information. I also bought TurboTax after claims were made that it now allows the signed attachment. I am yet to file since I'm still working on some business returns (S corp & partnership) that flow to my personal return. Hopefully the safe harbor statement was truly attached even though it didn't appear in your saved download file. If not I would hope this falls under TurboTax's 100% accuracy guarantee.
Thanks for the update and glad you were able to file.
Can anyone else confirm they were able to file with the QBI safe harbor form?
Had to pay an accountant $600 to re-type my completed TT tax return last year and and want to make sure i avoid that fiasco.
Well i can update that the Fed. and 3 other states all accepted my returns. And i received my Fed refund. So i'm taking that as everything was properly submitted. I'm 99.9% sure it was all properly filed anyway. Seems like the safe harbor is possibly treated like a worksheet?
Were you able to efile your return with this statement electronically. I have 4 rental properties to aggregate and have done so in past years. I did paper file in those years due to this statement. Do you have to continue to attach it each year and sign it each year?
The statement that is printing out for my return has the correct verbage but I am using the exception as I didn't have 250 hours this for 2021 but did in the other years. I don't want to send in something that says other than the truth.
Will I have to revise the statement to meet the exception and paper file my entire return, which is rather large?
Are you more likely to be audited if you paper file?
thanks for you help, I am rather late this year filing my return
I used TurboTax for my 2021 Income taxes and was able to attach the Rental Real Estate Enterprise Statement. I was not able to sign it but according to Rev. Proc. 2019-38 a signature is no longer required. I did however edit the form to include the following on the signature line “{my full name} digitally signed 4/4/22”, just in case.
I’m confused by what you are asking in regards to the 250 hours. This is a REQUIREMENT each year in order to claim the safe harbor. What exception are you referring to? In order to take the safe harbor you have to affirm that you spent 250 hours or more on the Real Estate Enterprise. Since you are aggregating it is 250 combined for all of you properties not 250 for each. Also, time spent on numerous things can qualify. See the end of my post as to what qualifies. Also, all services DO NOT have to be performed specifically by you to qualify.
Rev. Proc. 2019-38 does allow leniency in regards to the 250 hours IF the enterprise has been in existence for at least 4 years. Below is per Rev. Proc. 2019-38: Performance of 250 or more hours of rental services – for a rental real estate enterprise in existence for at least four years, at least 250 hours of rental services must have been performed annually in any three of the five preceding tax years.
Yes, your chances of getting audited are greater if you paper file. When you electronically file your tax data gets transferred automatically into the tax authorities system avoiding data input error. When you paper file all of your tax data has to be manually inputted into their system. As your tax return is comprised of numerous pages this provides greater chance that something will be entered incorrectly which may trigger an alert where your return has to be reviewed.
I am attaching some information which may be useful. I am also attaching the Aggregation & Enterprise forms I used with personal information X’d out.
Good luck.
The IRS previously released Notice 2019-07, which provided a proposed safe harbor under which a rental real estate enterprise would qualify as a trade or business solely for purposes of section 199A. The IRS finalized this guidance on Sept. 24, 2019 with the release of Rev. Proc. 2019-38. While substantially similar to Notice 2019-07, the new revenue procedure does deviate in some notable areas
250 Hours of Real Estate Rental Services
Such services don't all have to be performed by you, the property owner. They may also be performed by your employees, agents, or independent contractors. For example, if you hire a real estate management company, the time they spend managing your property counts toward the 250 hour requirement.
The following types of activities do not count toward the 250 hours:
I used TurboTax for my 2021 Income taxes and was able to attach the Rental Real Estate Enterprise Statement. I was not able to sign it but according to Rev. Proc. 2019-38 a signature is no longer required. I did however edit the form to include the following on the signature line “{my full name} digitally signed 4/4/22”, just in case.
I’m confused by what you are asking in regards to the 250 hours. This is a REQUIREMENT each year in order to claim the safe harbor. What exception are you referring to? In order to take the safe harbor you have to affirm that you spent 250 hours or more on the Real Estate Enterprise. Since you are aggregating it is 250 combined for all of you properties not 250 for each. Also, time spent on numerous things can qualify. See the end of my post as to what qualifies.
Rev. Proc. 2019-38 does allow leniency in regards to the 250 hours IF the enterprise has been in existence for at least 4 years. Below is per Rev. Proc. 2019-38: Performance of 250 or more hours of rental services – for a rental real estate enterprise in existence for at least four years, at least 250 hours of rental services must have been performed annually in any three of the five preceding tax years.
Yes, your chances of getting audited are greater if you paper file. When you electronically file your tax data gets transferred automatically into the tax authorities system avoiding data input error. When you paper file all of your tax data has to be manually inputted into their system. As your tax return is comprised of numerous pages this provides greater chance that something will be entered incorrectly which may trigger an alert where your return has to be reviewed.
I am attaching some information which may be useful. I am also attaching the Aggregation & Enterprise forms I used with personal information X’d out.
Good luck.
The IRS previously released Notice 2019-07, which provided a proposed safe harbor under which a rental real estate enterprise would qualify as a trade or business solely for purposes of section 199A. The IRS finalized this guidance on Sept. 24, 2019 with the release of Rev. Proc. 2019-38. While substantially similar to Notice 2019-07, the new revenue procedure does deviate in some notable areas
250 Hours of Real Estate Rental Services
Such services don't all have to be performed by you, the property owner. They may also be performed by your employees, agents, or independent contractors. For example, if you hire a real estate management company, the time they spend managing your property counts toward the 250 hour requirement.
The following types of activities do not count toward the 250 hours:
Thanks for all for all that good information. By "exception" I did mean the "at least 250 hours of rental services must have been performed annually in any three of the five preceding tax years". We have 4 rentals which require a lot of maintenance (wells and septics). 2021 we had no turnovers with COVID but usually we do and they take a ton of time. We have one coming up and it will be time consuming due to tenant damages, so I think we are safe to take the QBI for 2021.
I see no way to "edit" the QBI statement in my software. In fact that form doesn't even appear until I go to print the return. So if I were to edit Turbo Tax verbage about the 250 hours I would have to paper file, which I don't want to do. Any ideas?
I don't feel real comfortable sending in the verbage about the 250 hours when that's not exactly true.
My mistake, I found the form, it is there. I can't edit it. I could try to override but then it would eliminate my ability to efile. A CPA friend thinks it is OK to leave the verbage as is as I am relying on the software. I surely do not want to file my rather large return paper. (I had to file a paper return last year and I have had a lot of issues with the IRS sending small bills and saying there are computational errors etc when there aren't.
If you want to edit the RREE Statement and/or Schedule B (Form 8995-A) form you should be able to click- the View tab, then Forms then scroll down to the form to select. Within the various user data fields you should be able to change, add or delete.
In regards to the 250 hours you are responsible for maintaining a log of all related service hours however this log will likely never be seen by any tax authority unless the small chance you get audited. The possibilities for service hours are almost endless. I’ve seen many exaggerate the time & even log things whether or not they were actual. As long as a log is maintained and reasonable I don’t think the IRS or state would question it in the unlikely chance you were audited. FYI I am a CPA as well.
Good luck.
Still have questions?
Make a postAsk questions and learn more about your taxes and finances.
ldlittman
Level 2
Opus 17
Level 15
mill6210
Level 1
qhgnlm
Returning Member
Juancar
Returning Member
Did the information on this page answer your question?
You have clicked a link to a site outside of the TurboTax Community. By clicking "Continue", you will leave the Community and be taken to that site instead.