turbotax icon
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Announcements
Close icon
Do you have a TurboTax Online account?

We'll help you get started or pick up where you left off.

RMD 2023 messed up?

In May 2023, I withdrew an RMD from an Inherited IRA account and transferred it to an Inherited non-IRA account. I am thinking this may have been a mistake, and I would need to pay double tax  - once on the transfer out of the inherited IRA in 2023, and again in a future year when that money is withdrawn from the inherited non-IRA. How can I fix this in 2023? Should I transfer back the money into the Inherited IRA to 'reverse' the withdrawal, and then withdraw the RMD by transferring it to a non-inherited account? Or can I just withdraw the funds now in the non-IRA inherited account and not be required to report that to the IRS in 2023?   Thanks for any advice

x
Do you have an Intuit account?

Do you have an Intuit account?

You'll need to sign in or create an account to connect with an expert.

5 Replies

RMD 2023 messed up?

What kind of account is the non IRA?  You don't pay taxes on withdrawals from regular bank accounts.   Just on the interest.  If you put it in a brokerage account you only pay tax on the gains from sales.  

dmertz
Level 15

RMD 2023 messed up?

VolvoGirl asks the essential question:  What kind of account is the inherited non-IRA account?  Saying what it isn't is not particularly informative.

 

Nothing can be done to move this money back the the inherited IRA, nor would it be beneficial to do so.

RMD 2023 messed up?

Let's suppose you inherited some stocks or mutual fund investments held at a stock broker.  Those assets would all have received a stepped up value when the previous owner died, so you pay income tax on current interest and dividends, plus you would pay capital gains if you sell the investments based on the selling price compared to their value on the date of the previous owner's death.

 

If you add money to that investment account (it doesn't matter from where) then you are buying new shares at the price on the day you buy them.  You will pay tax on current interest and dividends, and you will pay capital gains tax if you sell the shares for more than you paid.  But you don't pay tax again on the original investment.  That's not a benefit of the account being inherited, that's how any investment is taxed.    If you had taken the RMD and put it in a regular savings account, you would pay tax on the interest.  If you had bought collectible comic books, you would pay tax on the increase in price (the gain) when you sell them.  If you put it in your mattress, you wouldn't pay any more tax, but you wouldnt have any more income from that money and it would gradually lose purchasing power due to inflation. 

RMD 2023 messed up?

Thanks for the reply, I was thinking that a non-IRA inherited account (this is a brokerage account) will be taxed on withdrawals like an inherited IRA account, but since the original owner already paid taxes, that is not correct. Taxes are paid like any other brokerage account, on interest, dividends, and cap gains.

RMD 2023 messed up?


@skullcandles wrote:

Thanks for the reply, I was thinking that a non-IRA inherited account (this is a brokerage account) will be taxed on withdrawals like an inherited IRA account, but since the original owner already paid taxes, that is not correct. Taxes are paid like any other brokerage account, on interest, dividends, and cap gains.


Correct, and you inherited a stepped up cost basis when the previous owner died, too. 

Unlock tailored help options in your account.

message box icon

Get more help

Ask questions and learn more about your taxes and finances.

Post your Question