I am a Head of Household filer and have two minor children in K-12 private school, for whom I take annual distributions from their respective 529 plans, of which I am the plan owner and they are the designated beneficiary, and pay for their tuition. The tuition total is greater than the $10,000 limit for K-12 education, so I expect to pay income tax and the 10% Additional Tax on the proportional earnings portion of the excess distributions. In past years, when I claimed both children as dependents, and Turbotax has calculated the tax exactly as I expected.
This year, for tax year 2021, one of my children will be claimed as a dependent by their other parent and, therefore, will appear in my return as a non-dependent. That change (from having the designated beneficiary on the 1099-Q as a dependent in past years to a non-dependent for 2021) has Turbotax calculating zero income tax or Additional Tax for the earnings portions of the excess distributions for that child. While this would be a pleasant surprise, it doesn't seem consistent with the tax code. For fun, I've swapped the children as dependent and non-dependent, and the result is consistent; the dependent child's excess distributions get calculated as I expect and the non-dependent child's excess distributions do not get taxed at all. I've also tried to force the worksheets for the non-dependent child to match what I expect the tax to be, but those fields aren't editable by me.
I'm looking for ideas... Am I missing something in the way I'm entering the data into Turbotax? Am I missing a pleasant surprise in the tax code? Or might this be an edge case that Turbotax doesn't handle as expected?
You'll need to sign in or create an account to connect with an expert.
When you enter the Tuition and Enrollment Fees for the non-dependent, please limit that entry to 10,000.
Only 10,000 of Elementary and Secondary education expenses can be claimed per student per tax year.
Thanks. That did indeed produce the results I was expecting. Not at all intuitive, or consistent with how dependent student expenses are handled, but a good enough work-around.
Still have questions?
Make a postAsk questions and learn more about your taxes and finances.
McC2incollege
Returning Member
taxi11
New Member
LB42
Level 1
TheBeaz
Level 2
LW31
Level 2
Did the information on this page answer your question?
You have clicked a link to a site outside of the TurboTax Community. By clicking "Continue", you will leave the Community and be taken to that site instead.