turbotax icon
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Announcements
Close icon
Do you have a TurboTax Online account?

We'll help you get started or pick up where you left off.

Should money from a student internship be considered EARNED or unearned in order to put the amount in roth IRA

Hi

We are claiming our college student son in our tax return. He received $4500 internship stipend with no w-2 or any 1099 form  through summer research at university of Chicago in year 2021 and would like to put this amount into his Roth IRA account.  Can he contribute  this amount in his Roth IRA? Should we report this stipend as option 1 earned ( use earned income +$350 standard deduction) or option 2 unearned income (pay child tax)? If option 1, how to report on Turbo tax?

 

Another question: Our home state is NJ. He goes to college at Massachusetts  and stipend is from Illinois ( he works from home and never live in IL ). If he files state tax return, which states he should file?

 

Thank  you so much and Best Regards!

 

x
Do you have an Intuit account?

Do you have an Intuit account?

You'll need to sign in or create an account to connect with an expert.

1 Best answer

Accepted Solutions

Should money from a student internship be considered EARNED or unearned in order to put the amount in roth IRA


@linhuisk wrote:

Hi Opus 17,

 

Yes, this stipend was paid by a different college than where he attends. So this is his only income and as you suggested that he do not need to file tax return.  And this stipend will also not be reported in our family return. Does this mean we do not need to report this stipend to IRS at all? 

 

Thanks.


Correct, it is not reported if it is less than your son's standard deduction of $12,550.

View solution in original post

13 Replies
ColeenD3
Expert Alumni

Should money from a student internship be considered EARNED or unearned in order to put the amount in roth IRA

In order to contribute to an IRA, it must be counted as earned income. You will file an NJ return, as it is his home state. Please see this additional information from Fern.

 

A scholarship or fellowship grant is tax free (excludable from gross income) only if you are a candidate for a degree at an eligible educational institution. Any amount of scholarship or fellowship that is greater than your education expenses is taxable.

If you have offsetting education expenses enter the scholarship or grant  as part of your education expenses.

Select Federal Taxes
Select Deductions and Credits
Select Show More at Education
Select Start or Update at Expenses and Scholarships (Form 1098T)
Select Edit at Scholarships/Grants (for all schools

If you do are not a candidate for a degree, or if you do not have offsetting education expenses, the fellowship should be reported as less common income.

• Select Federal Taxes
• Select Wages and Income
• Scroll down to Less Common Income and select Start or Review
• Select Start next to Miscellaneous Income 1099A, 1099C and enter the information provided on your form

See IRS Publication 970 for additional information.

Should money from a student internship be considered EARNED or unearned in order to put the amount in roth IRA

Hi ColeenD3

 

Thank you so much for quick reply. He is a candidate for a collage degree. But he did not use this $4500 internship stipend for any education expenses and he deposited it into his Roth IRA account for 2021 contribution. So in this case, he can not use Form 1098-T.  We will use Miscellaneous Income and it will end up Tax $301 after deduction of $ 1100. Is this correct?  After paying tax, the $ 4500 he deposited into his Roth IRA is allowed,  right? We would like to confirm that he is allowed to put $ 4500 into 2001 Roth IRA contribution after he files tax return.

 

Thanks. 

Should money from a student internship be considered EARNED or unearned in order to put the amount in roth IRA


@linhuisk wrote:

Hi ColeenD3

 

Thank you so much for quick reply. He is a candidate for a collage degree. But he did not use this $4500 internship stipend for any education expenses and he deposited it into his Roth IRA account for 2021 contribution. So in this case, he can not use Form 1098-T.  We will use Miscellaneous Income and it will end up Tax $301 after deduction of $ 1100. Is this correct?  After paying tax, the $ 4500 he deposited into his Roth IRA is allowed,  right? We would like to confirm that he is allowed to put $ 4500 into 2001 Roth IRA contribution after he files tax return.

 

Thanks. 


An internship is not a grant.  Or probably not.

 

The IRS says this,

Graduate or postdoctoral study.

A scholarship or fellowship is generally taxable compensation only if it is in box 1 of your Form W-2, Wage and Tax Statement. However, for tax years beginning after 2019, certain non-tuition fellowship and stipend payments not reported to you on Form W-2 are treated as taxable compensation for IRA purposes. These amounts include taxable non-tuition fellowship and stipend payments made to aid you in the pursuit of graduate or postdoctoral study and included in your gross income under the rules discussed in chapter 1 of Pub. 970, Tax Benefits for Education.

https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p970.pdf

 

 

To contribute to an IRA, he must have compensation.  Compensation is usually earned income (subject to social security withholding or self-employment tax), but compensation also includes taxable grants and fellowships as described above.

 

In most cases, a paid internship is not going to fall under the category of compensation, because it is not a grant or fellowship.  A paid internship is also not earned income, because if it is considered part of his education, he probably does not report it as self-employment income on schedule C.

 

I don't believe your son can contribute to an IRA if his only income is the internship.

 

If you believe the internship does counts as "non-tuition fellowship and scholarship" income under publication 970 (this is your risk to take), then in Turbotax, the only way to get Turbotax to recognize it as "compensation" is to enter it in the education expense interview, even though no 1098-T was issued.  If you enter it as misc income, the program will not recognize it as compensation and will tell you that IRA contributions are not allowed. 

Should money from a student internship be considered EARNED or unearned in order to put the amount in roth IRA

Hi Opus 17

 

Thank you so much for your reply. So he can not contribute this money to Roth IRA and this is his only income for 2021. I have two questions then. What is the proper way to report his $4500 stipend now? This amount is not on his 1098-T. And I already used his 1098-T for family tax return. Where to report on TurboTax?

How to remove $4500 from his Roth IRA. He will graduate  May 2022 and have income for 2022. Can he carry this amount forward to 2022 Roth IRA  contribution? Is there any penalty?  Does he need report this incident in 2021 tax return?

Thanks.

Should money from a student internship be considered EARNED or unearned in order to put the amount in roth IRA

@linhuisk 

For the Roth IRA, he needs to contact the custodian and request a “return of excess contributions. “The custodian must also return any earnings, if any.  The return of excess contribution must be completed before April 15. Since the contribution will have been returned within the tax year (under the meaning of the rules) he would simply not report the IRA contribution, it’s as if he never made it.  If there were earnings that were returned to him, they will be reported on a 1099R for 2022 and will be taxable at that time.


He could leave the money in the Roth IRA, in which case he would pay a 6% penalty this year. He could then count the 2021 excess as part of his 2022 contribution limit, with the result that it would not be excess any longer and would not be subject to an additional 6% tax.  It may seem odd that if he leaves the money in the account he pays a 6% penalty, but if he withdraws the money under the excess contribution rules and then re-deposits it the next week he doesn’t pay 6% penalty, but that’s the way the rules work.

 

For the internship, what kind of paperwork did he get if any, and who paid the stipend? A company would normally be required to issue a 1099-NEC or a 1099-MISC, unless the internship was paid by the school instead of the company he interned at. 

It sounds like he is an undergraduate? Or is he a graduate student, your original question was not clear. It would also be helpful to know whether he pays tuition, or receives fellowship or free tuition in any way.

 

Should money from a student internship be considered EARNED or unearned in order to put the amount in roth IRA

Hi opus 17,

 

He is an undergraduate and no any paper work ( no W-2 or 1099 form) was received for his 2021 summer internship stipend.

We pay tuitions and he receives some scholarship and there is 1098-T for 2021. We used this in our family return and claim him as dependent. So he will file his own tax return and where should he put this $4500 stipend with no-forms?

Do you know SECURE Act and does this only apply to graduate student?

Thanks.

Should money from a student internship be considered EARNED or unearned in order to put the amount in roth IRA


@linhuisk wrote:

Hi opus 17,

 

He is an undergraduate and no any paper work ( no W-2 or 1099 form) was received for his 2021 summer internship stipend.

We pay tuitions and he receives some scholarship and there is 1098-T for 2021. We used this in our family return and claim him as dependent. So he will file his own tax return and where should he put this $4500 stipend with no-forms?

Do you know SECURE Act and does this only apply to graduate student?

Thanks.


As quoted from publication 590-A, the definition of compensation was expanded to include "taxable non-tuition fellowship and stipend payments made to aid you in the pursuit of graduate or postdoctoral study".  Undergrad fellowships are not compensation for IRA purposes. 

 

I would report the stipend as miscellaneous other income.  It is not self-employment income and is not subject to self-employment tax or social security tax because the purpose of the internship was education, and not "work" (even though he may have performed work-like tasks).

 

He likely does not have to file a tax return at all.  He owes no income tax if his taxable income is less than $12,550, and he won't get anything from the American opportunity tax credit even if he files, because he is your dependent.  In fact, if he is your dependent, you should report his 1098-T on your tax return, not his.  In that case, his only other income being the stipend which is less than $12,550, he would not be required to file at all.

 

The state tax return situation may be complicated, which would be a good reason not to file at all, if you can avoid it.  Any taxpayer owes a state tax return to the state where they live (their permanent residence) that reports all their world-wide income.  If they live or work temporarily in another state, they owe a non-resident return to that state that reports income earned in that state only.  (The state where the business is located is irrelevant in most cases.  What counts is where the taxpayer physically lived and worked while earning the money, and where their permanent residence is.)

 

Permanent resident status is determined by where your domicile is located.  You can read here about how NJ determines domicile.  https://www.state.nj.us/treasury/taxation/pdf/pubs/tgi-ee/git6.pdf

To establish a new domicile, you must also take active steps to abandon your old domicile.  It is very likely that your son is domiciled in NJ, at least for now, no matter how long he stays in MA.

 

So if he files a tax return, he must file an NJ resident return, because NJ is likely still his permanent home, with MA being "temporary" (at least for now).  However, if he earned part or all of the stipend while living or working within the state of MA, he also must file a MA non-resident return that reports and pays tax on the portion of his income that was paid while living or working within MA.  To reduce the burden of being taxed in 2 states on the same money, NJ will give him a credit against any tax he pays in MA. 

 

But again, if he is your dependent, you should report the 1098-T on your tax return; and he is not required to file if his only income is less than $12,550.  (However, if he decides to leave the money in the Roth, he will be required to file to pay that penalty, even though his income won't be taxable.)

Should money from a student internship be considered EARNED or unearned in order to put the amount in roth IRA

Hi Opus 17,

Thank you for your reply.  I will report 1098-T in family return. But this $ 4500 stipend is not on 1098-T. Should I edit 1098-T on Turbo Tax and  add this amount to the amount in box 5 of 1098-T?

 

Thanks.

Should money from a student internship be considered EARNED or unearned in order to put the amount in roth IRA


@linhuisk wrote:

Hi Opus 17,

Thank you for your reply.  I will report 1098-T in family return. But this $ 4500 stipend is not on 1098-T. Should I edit 1098-T on Turbo Tax and  add this amount to the amount in box 5 of 1098-T?

 

Thanks.


You said the stipend was paid by a different college than where he attends and where you paid tuition, right?  So the tuition is whatever you paid to the college in MA, and is reported on your return since your son is your dependent.

 

The stipend is his income and would be reported as misc income on his return, except that he does not have to file at all if his income is less than $12,550. 

Should money from a student internship be considered EARNED or unearned in order to put the amount in roth IRA

Hi Opus 17,

 

Yes, this stipend was paid by a different college than where he attends. So this is his only income and as you suggested that he do not need to file tax return.  And this stipend will also not be reported in our family return. Does this mean we do not need to report this stipend to IRS at all? 

 

Thanks.

Should money from a student internship be considered EARNED or unearned in order to put the amount in roth IRA


@linhuisk wrote:

Hi Opus 17,

 

Yes, this stipend was paid by a different college than where he attends. So this is his only income and as you suggested that he do not need to file tax return.  And this stipend will also not be reported in our family return. Does this mean we do not need to report this stipend to IRS at all? 

 

Thanks.


Correct, it is not reported if it is less than your son's standard deduction of $12,550.

sect199a
New Member

Should money from a student internship be considered EARNED or unearned in order to put the amount in roth IRA

I am not a tax expert. My child is in a similar situation. My understanding is that because the child in this question is a dependent, on his tax return his standard deduction is the greater of $1100 or his 'earned income' plus $350, both capped at the non-dependent single standard deduction of $12,500. Since the child has no earned income, he would be required to file a return, and pay income tax on all but $1100 of the stipend. 

Should money from a student internship be considered EARNED or unearned in order to put the amount in roth IRA


@sect199a wrote:

I am not a tax expert. My child is in a similar situation. My understanding is that because the child in this question is a dependent, on his tax return his standard deduction is the greater of $1100 or his 'earned income' plus $350, both capped at the non-dependent single standard deduction of $12,500. Since the child has no earned income, he would be required to file a return, and pay income tax on all but $1100 of the stipend. 


No.  Even though a scholarship in excess of tuition is "unearned income" for most tax purposes, it is considered "earned income" for the kiddie tax.   See here,

https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p929.pdf

message box icon

Get more help

Ask questions and learn more about your taxes and finances.

Post your Question