I'm using TurboTax Premium Online. I enter "Federal" -> "Other tax situations" -> "Other tax situations summary" -> "Form W4 and Estimated Taxes" -> "Estimates", where I fill out my expectation for ...
See more...
I'm using TurboTax Premium Online. I enter "Federal" -> "Other tax situations" -> "Other tax situations summary" -> "Form W4 and Estimated Taxes" -> "Estimates", where I fill out my expectation for this year's income, withholding, etc., making sure that the question "Copy current year wage information to next year" is answered with "*No*". For this year's W-2, the "Expected federal tax withholding" amount I enter is much smaller than last year's. At the end of this entry flow, the TurboTax estimate for "2026 taxable income" and "2026 tax" seem correct. On that screen, for estimated tax payment calculation method I select "100% of tax on your estimated 2026 estimated taxable income". On the next screen, TurboTax declares "Based on your entries, you have no estimated tax payment liability", which is bogus because the entered estimated withheld taxes for 2026 do not cover the estimate for the "2026 tax" by far. If I use the estimated tax payment calculation method "100% (110%) of your actual 2025 taxes" instead, I do get estimated tax payments, but the amounts are significantly too low. When I then go to "Tax Tools" -> "Print Center" and print the "2025 Federal return" -> "Include government and TurboTax worksheets", I can see the worksheet "Amount of Estimated Taxes to Pay in 2026" contains the line "Expected withholding for 2026" filled in with "(*2025 actual withholding*)" followed by last year's amount. This is where the TurboTax calculation error comes from: It ignores the information I entered for expected 2026 W2 withholding and instead uses last year's numbers, which I explicitly told it not to use. How do I fix this?