turbotax icon
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
turbotax icon
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
Announcements
Attend our Ask the Experts event about Deciphering Your Tax Forms on Feb 19! >> RSVP NOW!
Close icon
Do you have a TurboTax Online account?

We'll help you get started or pick up where you left off.

Question about why I have to pay so much in CA taxes

Hello,

 

My total income was $78,176 (box 1 on my W2), and I paid $1,888 in state income tax (box 17 on my W-2). After doing my taxes, it says I will owe the CA state $1,256 and that I am getting a $0 federal refund.

 

Do those numbers sound correct for me to have to pay that much in CA taxes? I just want to make sure that I am doing my taxes right before submitting them.

 

I provided some numbers below for context from my last few W-2's to compare how much CA taxes have been withheld over time:

 

From looking at the percentages below, a lesser percentage of state income taxes is being withheld from my paycheck every year. Even though I am making more money every year. I think that is why gradually I have been getting less of a tax refund and I actually owe money to the CA state. Back in 2022 I made less money, but a higher percentage of about 0.038% was taken out of my paychecks. In comparison to 2024 were I make a lot more money, but only about 0.024% is withheld from my paychecks towards CA taxes.

 

W-2 2024 - (Box 16) $78,176 x 0.024% = $1,876.22 (closest number I could compute to $1,888.63)

State income tax / Box 17 = $1,888.63

 

W-2 2023 - (Box 16) $72,870 x 0.038% = 2,769.96  (closest number I could compute to $2,746.22)

State income tax / Box 17 = $2,746.22

 

W-2 2022 - (Box 16) $63,877 x 0.044% =$2,810,58  (closest number I could compute to $2,796.17)

State income tax / Box 17 = $2,796.17

 

Thanks for your help.

Best regards,

x
Do you have an Intuit account?

Do you have an Intuit account?

You'll need to sign in or create an account to connect with an expert.

2 Replies
RobertB4444
Employee Tax Expert

Question about why I have to pay so much in CA taxes

As your income has increased the amount of taxes being taken out of your paycheck for California has gone down.  That is why you owe.  Time to have a word with HR.

 

@BerkeleyBabe2017 

**Say "Thanks" by clicking the thumb icon in a post
**Mark the post that answers your question by clicking on "Mark as Best Answer"

Question about why I have to pay so much in CA taxes

Thanks for confirming my suspicions, RobertB4444!

 

Please excuse my typo that I have underlined and bolded below:

 

Hello,

 

My total income was $78,176 (box 1 on my W2), and I paid $1,888 in state income tax (box 17 on my W-2). After doing my taxes, it says I will owe the CA state $1,256 and that I am getting a $0 federal refund.

 

Do those numbers sound correct for me to have to pay that much in CA taxes? I just want to make sure that I am doing my taxes right before submitting them.

 

I provided some numbers below for context from my last few W-2's to compare how much CA taxes have been withheld over time:

 

From looking at the percentages below, a lesser percentage of state income taxes is being withheld from my paycheck every year. Even though I am making more money every year. I think that is why gradually I have been getting less of a tax refund and I actually owe money to the CA state. Back in 2022 I made less money, but a higher percentage of about 0.044% was taken out of my paychecks. In comparison to 2024 were I make a lot more money, but only about 0.024% is withheld from my paychecks towards CA taxes.

 

W-2 2024 - (Box 16) $78,176 x 0.024% = $1,876.22 (closest number I could compute to $1,888.63)

State income tax / Box 17 = $1,888.63

 

W-2 2023 - (Box 16) $72,870 x 0.038% = 2,769.96  (closest number I could compute to $2,746.22)

State income tax / Box 17 = $2,746.22

 

W-2 2022 - (Box 16) $63,877 x 0.044% =$2,810,58  (closest number I could compute to $2,796.17)

State income tax / Box 17 = $2,796.17

 

Thanks for your help.

Best regards,

message box icon

Get more help

Ask questions and learn more about your taxes and finances.

Post your Question