Solved: Need help with $6500 Excess Contribution made in 2017. Amending 2017 Return but "P" Code is indicating "Taxable in 2016."
Sign Up

Why sign in to the Community?

  • Submit a question
  • Check your notifications
or and start working on your taxes
Announcements
TurboTax has you covered during Covid. Get the latest stimulus info here.
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
ClareCA
Level 2

Need help with $6500 Excess Contribution made in 2017. Amending 2017 Return but "P" Code is indicating "Taxable in 2016."

TurboTax says I need to amend my return for 2017.  The Code P is saying that they were taxable in 2016.  They didn't earn earnings until 2017.  My 2017 contributions were reversed before the filing date in April, 2018. 

Update:  I did amend my 2017 return as I understand that I am supposed to in order to report the earnings.  The 2018 1099R that I received in 2019 has the Code PJ.  When I entered this code into my Amended 2017 tax form, "P" now stands for Taxable in 2016, which I don't think is right, but I didn't change the Code.

Any help is appreciated.

1 Best answer

Accepted Solutions
Rachel_W
Level 4

Need help with $6500 Excess Contribution made in 2017. Amending 2017 Return but "P" Code is indicating "Taxable in 2016."

When you enter your Form 1099-R when Amending your 2017 Tax Return, the code "P" will say "taxable in 2016"; however, in the next step, you should be asked if this is a 2017 or 2018 1099-R.  When you choose "2018", the year advances by one. 

Note: Code "P" is always one year before the issue year on the 1099-R.

If you need further assistance regarding this issue, please comment below.

View solution in original post

2 Replies
Rachel_W
Level 4

Need help with $6500 Excess Contribution made in 2017. Amending 2017 Return but "P" Code is indicating "Taxable in 2016."

When you enter your Form 1099-R when Amending your 2017 Tax Return, the code "P" will say "taxable in 2016"; however, in the next step, you should be asked if this is a 2017 or 2018 1099-R.  When you choose "2018", the year advances by one. 

Note: Code "P" is always one year before the issue year on the 1099-R.

If you need further assistance regarding this issue, please comment below.

View solution in original post

ClareCA
Level 2

Need help with $6500 Excess Contribution made in 2017. Amending 2017 Return but "P" Code is indicating "Taxable in 2016."

Thank you, Rachel!  I do have some follow-up questions if you are available.  I put them in a new question, but here is what I wrote if you have the time:

2016:  I contributed $6500 to my Roth IRA in February, 2017, for Tax Year 2016, which was an excess contribution which was withdrawn in January, 2018.  I just received that 1099R in 2019. I have amended my 2016 return and reported the excess contributions and I am assuming I have to pay a 6% penalty on that contribution because it was not withdrawn by April, 2017.  There are two 2016 5329's for my husband and myself with Lines 23 and 24 having $6500 each.

2017:  I also contributed $6500 during the year of 2017, which was also reversed in January, 2018, and I am amending my 2017 return and reporting the withdrawn contributions and earnings and paying a 10% penalty on the earnings.  My husband did the same but is over 591/2, and so no 10% penalty for him. Since I withdrew the 2016 $6500 before the tax filing in 2018, I am unsure if that goes on my amended 2017 taxes.  I already have a distribution of $6500 for 2017 taxes on a different 1099R with earnings that I am putting there. Forms 5329 have $6500 on Lines 18, 20, and 21 in Part IV.  Two Forms 8606 for my husband and me have $6500 on Lines 19, 21, and 22.  

2018:  I contributed $542 to my IRA Roth in January, 2018, but those were reversed later that month with the earnings.  I reported the $6500 Distribution from January, 2018, on my 2018 Return which was the initial 2016 contribution.  On the 5329, Lines 20 and 21 have $6500 each, and on the 8606, Lines 19 and 21 and 22 have $6500.

Question 1: am correct in Amending my 2016 taxes and paying the 6% penalty in that return for not withdrawing by April, 2017?

Question 2: do I pay a 6% penalty in the 2017 Return for the 2016 contribution even though it was withdrawn before the tax filing date of April, 2018?

Question 3: Are the 5329 and 8606 Forms for all three years filled out correctly to reflect all this?
Many thanks for your help and assistance!

Dynamic AdsDynamic Ads
v
Privacy Settings