I am using TurboTax Deluxe Desktop edition to complete my taxes. I believe TurboTax is populating Form 2441 incorrectly based on the information I provide it.
I initially used the EasyStep interface to calculate the Child and Dependent Care Credit and was surprised to see that my calculated tax credit is 0. Digging into Form 2441, I believe TurboTax generates this form erroneously.
I was a full-time student for all 12 months of 2023 with zero earned income while my spouse has W2 income. Box B on Form 2441 is checked to indicate that I am entering in deemed income of $500/month for my earned income calculation.
Scrolling down to the box below line 4, Box A correctly indicates 12 months and Box B correctly indicates $6000 under "Taxpayer" column. However, line 4 "Enter your earned income" is populated with 0 (taken from the earned income worksheet), instead of the $6000 calculated in the box below. Line 4 is a calculated number which means that I can't seem to edit it manually.
The implication is that line 6 takes the smallest of line 3 ($6000 in eligible childcare expenses), line 4 (my earned income, which should be $6000 but TurboTax is using 0), and line 5 (my spouse's W2 income, which is > $6000), and then multiplies it by the decimal percentage on line 8 (0.2 in my case). So, my tax credit is calculated to be 0*0.2=0, instead of 6000*0.2 = $1200.
Can anyone see an error in how I am using TurboTax, or is this truly an error with TurboTax software itself? Appreciate any and all help.
You'll need to sign in or create an account to connect with an expert.
I think I figured out what is going on here.
In EasyStep, TurboTax asks you "Did you work while you were a student during those 12 months?". I had clicked "Yes", because (in my case) I was technically working but paid through fellowships (reported on 1098-T) and not W-2 income. Since I received more than $500/month in fellowship payments, I selected "Yes" for the subsequent TurboTax prompt. Then, on the next page, "We Need Some More Info to Calculate Your Credit", I entered in 12*500 = 6000. Note that TurboTax, under Step 2, says "We'll then take ***'s income of zero and update the qualifying income used to calculate this credit".
If you complete EasyStep this way, then Line 4 on Form 2441 ignores the box to estimate deemed income from being a full-time student and instead pulls directly from the Earned Income worksheet (which is zero in my case).
I fixed the problem for my tax return by instead selecting "No" for the EasyStep question "Did you work while you were a student during those 12 months?". Now, form 2441 enters $6000 on line 4 and my tax credit is calculated correctly.
Still have questions?
Make a postAsk questions and learn more about your taxes and finances.
NameForYou
Level 2
vp18276shm_fh
Level 2
reevarcoe
Level 1
kb115_
Level 2
hagert06
New Member
Did the information on this page answer your question?
You have clicked a link to a site outside of the TurboTax Community. By clicking "Continue", you will leave the Community and be taken to that site instead.