If you want to be sure not to pay next year, then have her list the 2 allowances and you list 0 allowances.
The higher income earner will then have more taxes taken out during the tax year. The more allowances the less tax is withheld.
Also remember the standard deduction for married goes to $24,000 so you may not be itemizing for 2018, as the mortgage interest, taxes, contributions, state taxes, etc, have to exceed this amount before it impacts the taxes.