"IND-032-04 - 'SpousePriorYearPIN' or 'SpousePriorYearAGIAmt' in the Return Header must match the e-File database" Error

Me and my wife filed jointly last year (printed and mailed) and are filing this the same this year.

When I tried to e-file this year with our joint AGI from last year, the return was rejected: "IND-032-04 - 'SpousePriorYearPIN' or 'SpousePriorYearAGIAmt' in the Return Header must match the e-File database".

I tried setting:

My AGI = our true AGI and her AGI = our true AGI
My AGI = our true AGI and her AGI = 0
0 as the AGI for both of us

I confirmed our PINs are correct. Though her PIN was set a few days ago and mine was set in 2022.
Is it possible the reason for the error is because she just set her PIN?

posted