No, you do not want to check Box 2 to indicate Ordinary Gain.
You need to make an adjustment to the cost basis on the 1099-B so that it includes the amount on your Supplemental statement. That same amount should have been included on your Form W-2, Box 1 as ordinary income. On the TurboTax entry page, just below the Box 2 Entry, is a box to enter the corrected cost basis. That should be the amount reported on the 1099-B plus the amount on the supplemental statement. You may want to click on the box on the previous screen for "Guide me step-by-step".