2024 Form 1099-R with a distribution code of P2

[kat469]

In 2023 I contributed $5000 to my Traditional IRA. 

When filing my 2023 taxes, I realized that I would not get a deduction for that contribution, so before the 2023 tax filing deadline, I had Fidelity distribute the contribution back to me. 

Fidelity distributed $6644.07 back to me in the beginning of 2024. 

I received a 2024 1099-R.  The 2024 Form 1099-R shows $1644.07 in box 2a (the  taxable amount).

I did have Fidelity withhold Federal Income tax of $164.40, but I think I still owe a little more federal income tax.

When I entered the 2024 1099-R into my 2024 taxes, Turbotax does not show that I owe any additional tax. 

Do I need to amend my 2023 taxes in order to finish paying taxes on the taxable amount?

[Mike9241]

The 2023 IRA contribution was non-deductible so getting the $5K back would not be taxable. only the earnings should be taxable 

[kat469]

I do understand that only the earnings are taxable.  I still need to know the answer to the question I asked.