Bug Report: Schedule 1-A Validation Error (Pre-Tax Distortion)Issue: The e-file validation script for the Section 225 Overtime Deduction (Schedule 1-A) is triggering a false-positive "Reasonableness" error by incorrectly using W-2 Box 1 as the denominator for its calculations instead of W-2 Box 3. I spent nearly 2 hours on the phone today with technical support. I am not 100% confident this bug is being followed up on. My Diagnostic Token is: [removed]-96664364 Technical Details:The Conflict: The software assumes a "Qualified Overtime Premium" cannot exceed 1/3 of total wages. My entry is exactly 1/3 of my Gross Wages (Box 3), but it appears as 46% of my Taxable Wages (Box 1).The Root Cause: The validation logic fails to account for Box 12 pre-tax contributions (e.g., 403b/401k). These contributions "shrink" Box 1, creating a mathematical distortion that falsely flags a perfectly legal 1.5x overtime premium ratio.The Impact: This error prevents e-filing for employees whose overtime work is significant and whose pre-tax retirement contributions are high, even when the data matches the W-2 perfectly.Steps to Reproduce:Enter a W-2 where 100% of the work is overtime (common for dual-role employees under the same EIN).Include a significant pre-tax contribution in Box 12.Attempt to claim the 33.3% overtime premium deduction on Schedule 1-A.The software will block e-filing, citing that the overtime cannot be more than 1/3 of Box 1.Thanks!

Box 1 of the W-2 is the correct box to use when evaluating overtime. Box 3 is Social Security wages. However, I'd like to understand a couple of things. You're a dual-role employeeThis W-2 is 100% overtime.You should have a second W-2 with the same EIN for the straight-time portion of your dual role?Combine the two W-2's that are from the same EIN.The IRS will recognise the two EINs as the same and do the same calculation.This will resolve the 33,3% overtime issue. Contact us again with any additional details.

TurboTax

File with experts
File your taxes
Experts at your fingertips

An expert helps with your taxes, or does them for you
TurboTax Expert Full Service

TurboTax Expert Assist

TurboTax Self-Employed
Prior year taxes
File myself
File myself
Do it yourself

We'll guide you step-by-step
TurboTax Do It Yourself

TurboTax Self-Employed

TurboTax Desktop
TurboTax Free

Activate your product

Prior year taxes
Business
Business
Business taxes

Get your T2 corporate return done right, your way
TurboTax Business

TurboTax Business Desktop
Tax situations
Tax situations
Tax situations

Find extra guidance for your big life moves
For investors

For 25 and younger

For self-employed

For new to Canada

For life changes
Resources
Resources
Resources

Explore tax tools, get tips, and read reviews
Personal income tax calculator

RRSP savings calculator

Learning hub

TurboTax support (FAQ)

TurboTax community
Pricing

HotToddy

Level 2

Question

Overtime Validation Bug (Desktop Version)

Forum|Forum|2 months ago
March 20, 2026
1 reply
2 views

Bug Report: Schedule 1-A Validation Error (Pre-Tax Distortion)

Issue: The e-file validation script for the Section 225 Overtime Deduction (Schedule 1-A) is triggering a false-positive "Reasonableness" error by incorrectly using W-2 Box 1 as the denominator for its calculations instead of W-2 Box 3.

I spent nearly 2 hours on the phone today with technical support. I am not 100% confident this bug is being followed up on. My Diagnostic Token is: [removed]-96664364

Technical Details:

The Conflict: The software assumes a "Qualified Overtime Premium" cannot exceed 1/3 of total wages. My entry is exactly 1/3 of my Gross Wages (Box 3), but it appears as 46% of my Taxable Wages (Box 1).
The Root Cause: The validation logic fails to account for Box 12 pre-tax contributions (e.g., 403b/401k). These contributions "shrink" Box 1, creating a mathematical distortion that falsely flags a perfectly legal 1.5x overtime premium ratio.
The Impact: This error prevents e-filing for employees whose overtime work is significant and whose pre-tax retirement contributions are high, even when the data matches the W-2 perfectly.

Steps to Reproduce:

Enter a W-2 where 100% of the work is overtime (common for dual-role employees under the same EIN).
Include a significant pre-tax contribution in Box 12.
Attempt to claim the 33.3% overtime premium deduction on Schedule 1-A.
The software will block e-filing, citing that the overtime cannot be more than 1/3 of Box 1.

Thanks!

TurboTax Home & Biz Windows

JohnB5677

Level 15

Box 1 of the W-2 is the correct box to use when evaluating overtime. Box 3 is Social Security wages. However, I'd like to understand a couple of things.

You're a dual-role employee
This W-2 is 100% overtime.
You should have a second W-2 with the same EIN for the straight-time portion of your dual role?

Combine the two W-2's that are from the same EIN.

The IRS will recognise the two EINs as the same and do the same calculation.

This will resolve the 33,3% overtime issue.

**Say "Thanks" by clicking the thumb icon in a post. **Mark the post that answers your question by clicking on "Mark as Best Answer"

HotToddyAuthor

Level 2

Thank you for the response, but combining the W-2s is not a viable solution for several reasons:

Different EINs: These W-2s are from separate divisions within the same corporation and carry different Employer Identification Numbers (EINs). Combining them would cause an IRS mismatch error and is not an option.
Separate Capacities: One role is salaried (Standard Time), while the other is strictly hourly (100% Overtime). This is not a 'dual role' under a single payroll record; they are distinct entries.

The Root Mathematical Error Remains:

The issue isn't how the data is entered; it’s the denominator the validation script uses for the 'Reasonableness' check.

The Box 1 Distortion: Box 1 represents taxable wages after pre-tax contributions (401k/403b). For any employee who saves for retirement, Box 1 is significantly lower than their actual gross earnings.
The Logic Failure: By using Box 1 as the denominator, the software creates a false-positive error.
- Example: Gross Wages (Box 5) = $100,000. Overtime = $33,333 (Exactly 1/3, which is legal).
- The Savings Penalty: If that person contributes $23,000 to a 401k, their Box 1 becomes $77,000.
- The Bug: TurboTax then calculates $33,333 \div 77,000 = 43.2\%.
- The Result: The software blocks the e-file because $43.2\% > 33.3\%, even though the overtime is exactly 1/3 of the earned wages.

The Requested Fix:

This validation script should be updated to compare the Schedule 1-A entry against Box 5 (Medicare Wages), which represents true gross earnings and does not 'shrink' based on retirement contributions.

Please escalate this to the Product Integrity / Calculations Team. This bug effectively prevents any taxpayer with significant overtime and high retirement savings from e-filing.

JohnB5677

Level 15

I don't understand.

If you work for a company that has two different EINs, you essentially work for two different companies.
You confirmed this when you said that you couldn't combine the W-2s.
If that is true you work for one company that pays a fixed wage,
You work for another company that evidently pays you that wage plus 50%
You don't have any overtime.

**Say "Thanks" by clicking the thumb icon in a post. **Mark the post that answers your question by clicking on "Mark as Best Answer"