Yes, you would list the expenses you paid in December of 2023 for Spring 2024 on your 2024 tax return, and not the amount you paid in December 2024 for Spring 2025.
The IRS specifically addresses this situation in Publication 503, and states: "If you pay for services before they are provided, you can count the prepaid expenses only in the year the care is received. Claim the expenses for the later year as if they were actually paid in that later year."