@user17545861291 thank you for your responses.
(a) Since this was not income property i.e. treated like a second home, you report the sale on Schedule-D where the basis is the acquisition cost ...
See more...
@user17545861291 thank you for your responses.
(a) Since this was not income property i.e. treated like a second home, you report the sale on Schedule-D where the basis is the acquisition cost ( in US$ of the time and including any closing costs --- as I understand one often gets "beneficial possession " and one still pays for the additional monies to make the place habitable after the final payment to the "promoter " ) and "sales price" includes sales proceeds less expenses related to the transaction ( such painting, cleaning, repairs, commission, transfer tax etc. , again in US$ ). Keep good records of how you came to the final /reported figures -- just in case there is a challenge.
(b) If there is a gain, then that gain is the amount that is being taxed by both US and India ( irrespective of what India gain is ). If India shows a loss and US shows a gain OR if India shows a gain but US shows a loss then there is no double taxation i.e. two jurisdictions both levying tax on the same foreign source income.
(c) Since you said that per US laws, you show a loss in the transaction ( mostly caused by exchange rate ? ), you have no US taxes levied on the transaction. However, this is still a long-term capital asset transaction and thus is eligible for capital loss treatment -- use / carry-back/carry-forward etc.
(d) Because the US return shows a loss position, there is no US tax levied and therefore there is NO FTC and no need for form 1116.
(e) As you can see from the above , your best strategy is to pursue reduction in Indian tax on the transaction and use the US capital loss to the extent allowable.
While I don't know the exact facts of this case, I must express my surprise at US loss -- in 2006 the exchange rate was in the 50s per US$ while in 2024 it was in the 80s. However in the same period , my impression was that housing prices have risen hugely. I have not been there since October 2006 and so this is all just gut feeling but I is surprised. Of course , it all depends on where the asset is and the environment there .
Is there more I can do for you ?
Namaste ji
pk