The miscalculation comes from Intuit using the wrong factor to multiply for the age. Intuit is halving the factor, in this case from 24.6 to 12.3 (if you follow the math, you will see the problem). This doubles the RMD requirement and results in a reporting of a substantial penalty. I hope that does not affect all RMD calculations for those filing returns. I hope that it is only my return. Be aware of this issue if you have RMD's to report and check your numbers! Do not rely on the Intuit calculation unless you confirm manually in your case that it is accurate. There are IRS charts to determine the divisor based on your age to apply to your balance as of December 31, 2024 for your 2025 RMD.