Should I use my new address we moved in September or should I use my old address?

@mpetrie403 

The address to use on your 2024 return Form 1040 is the current address to which you want the IRS to contact you by mail about any issues with the 2024 return. It's also the address to which they would mail a check for a tax refund if a direct deposit failed.

I have 2 w-2s with my current address and 3 with my old address 

You need to use your current address. It's the address that the IRS will use to contact you if needed. 

When you enter your W-2's, you can enter the address that's on the W-2. Refer to the TurboTax article What if my address on my W-2 is wrong?

Refer to the TurboTax article How do I change my address with the IRS?