Why sign in to the Community?

  • Submit a question
  • Check your notifications
Sign in to the Community or Sign in to TurboTax and start working on your taxes
New Member
posted Apr 12, 2024 1:28:36 PM

Federasl Information worksheet spouse dependent marked no but TTAX error check says form 8889-S linen 3A1 family should not checked

Running TTAX desktop.  Error check provided error" Form 8889-S Line 3A1 Family should not be checked. you indicated on the federal information worksheet that spouse could be claimed as a dependent of another...

 

I find the Federal information worksheet and spouse is NOT listed as a dependent of another - which mean the error message is WRONG.

 

Also looked at From 8889-S and there is no Line 3A1

0 5 3202
5 Replies
Expert Alumni
Apr 12, 2024 5:27:48 PM

So you looked at the following:

 

 

And on Part II, line one, is marked as NO. This is the spouse's Personal Worksheet on my test return (all info is made up). So your spouse's worksheet is marked the same way?

 

In the My Info/Personal Info section, you'll see

 

 

Is this unchecked for your spouse?

 

If you are still having this issue, I wonder if you checked this box by accident in the process of initially enter your spouse's data. If so, I would suggest deleting your spouse and re-entering your spouse.

 

We do millions of returns here, and I don't recall seeing a case in which this error message was produced incorrectly.

 

Oh, here is Line 3A1:

 

 

New Member
Apr 14, 2024 2:07:51 PM

Thank you for your  reply.

 

I notice in your screen shots that "Marital Status" is shown as "Single" - does this make a different.  We were married, so "single" would be incorrect and does not seem right because then there would be married filing separately.  I will assume that this does not matter as you are merely trying to help with the screen shots.  This field , "Martial Status" is set at "Married in my TTAX return

 

On my return, on the Personal Wks (Spouse name), Part II, line 1 the box is checked as "NO" 

 

 

On the Federal Information Worksheet Part I ("Personal Information") "Dependent of Someone Else, the NO box is checked for the line "Can spouse be claimed as a dependent of another person (such as a parent")

 

 

You directed my attention to "In the My Info/Personal Info section, you'll see".  I did not find a form for this, so I went back through the Easy Step Personal Info Summary for my spouse.  I did not change anything.  I reconfirmed all of the answers  (kept choosing "Continue" after reviewing the information)  in the Easy Step Personal Information workflow.  I note that the Easy Step query about spouse claimed as a dependent also has the NO box checked.

 

 

 

I have not been able to find a section that looks exactly like the image you displayed.

 

I also looked at the 1040 form itself.

- Filing Status is listed as "Married filing Separately"

- Under "Spouse Standard deduction" the Box is NOT checked for "Someone can claim your spouse as a dependent"

 

 

I respect your comment: "We do millions of returns here, and I don't recall seeing a case in which this error message was produced incorrectly."  However, I have combed through the forms and data in TTAX --with your guidance-- and I have not been able to find any place where my spouse is listed as a dependent.

 

The error message says ". . . . You indicated on the Federal Information Wks the your spouse could be claimed as a dependent of another . . ."  This is an untrue statement, as when I look at the Federal Informaiton Worksheet  The NO box is checked for the line "Can spouse be claimed as a dependent of another person (such as a parent")

 

 

 

 

I appreciate the time you took to provide a detailed answer, but the error remains.  Is there some hidden place in TTAX where this is set that we have not yet searched?

 

I will try to figure out how to delete my spouse and and then put her back in TTAX, I hope this does not mean I need to start over.

 

If you have any further suggestions, please let me know.  I appreciate your assistance.

 

Expert Alumni
Apr 15, 2024 8:39:04 AM

Go to MY INFO section of your return and delete all of your spouse's information. Then log out of your return to save the change. Log back in and reenter the information.  Be sure to check she cannot be a dependent of someone else. 

 

Let us know if this helps. 

New Member
Apr 15, 2024 1:05:50 PM

Hi There - I am running into the same issue and tried your recommended steps. This didn't work. Do you have any other recommendations? 

Expert Alumni
Apr 15, 2024 2:32:43 PM

@sgriffin14 

 

So, do you have the exact same error message? Are you filing Married Filing Separately?