How should I deduct items that were purchased from a charity's Amazon wish list and were shipped directly to the charity? Should I submit them as cash or goods?

When Amazon shipped out my order, they separated the order into three shipments.  Two were approximately $50 and one was approximately $125.  I received an email receipt from Amazon for the order and I have all of the items listed with their costs.  I wasn't sure how to enter the charity donation on ItsDeductible - goods or cash?