I received a 1099 R with amount containing Post 86 After Tax amount that had amount I contributed and amount gain in 401K. The actual after tax amount was moved into Roth IRA and the amount gained (not taxed) was moved into an IRA. I don't see in Turbo Tax how to separate this. It expects it to be either one or the other. Do I need to request a 1099R with them separate?
No, you do not need a new 1099R. The program will allow you to enter the numbers separately into what was contributed/rolled where.
Clarifying: one 1099R from a 401k with a basis of after tax dollars plus gain. The after tax dollars were moved into a Roth IRA. The gain was moved into some type of IRA.
If you are having trouble, you may want to contact a specialist that can work through that section of the return with you. It is a very particular process.