Which amount do I enter if I have two different amounts for my State wages?

What do you mean by that?  Two different states with different amounts?  Or something else?

There are two line items with two different amounts in Box 16 State wages, tips, etc. 

See there's two different amounts and I am not sure which to use.

Add them up to be safe! appears One is wage and other is Tips ; I am seeing you have 2 Tax deducted - add them up too

I'm pretty sure you need to report both.  The two numbers are amounts earned in two separate localities within the state.  Your total state wages is the total of both.