It seems that there might be an erroneous box checked on your W-2 input.
Here's how to check this in TurboTax Online:
- Navigate to Federal Taxes, Wages & Income, Job (W-2), Add/Edit
- On the next page select your W-2
- Continue through information about company
- Continue through "Now let's update the rest"
- On the Do any of these uncommon situations apply to this W-2? screen, be sure the box for Religious employment is not selected, then select Continue.