My 1095-A totals are cheaper than the TT totals. Annual Totals 4758.70 , 5763.96 , 4758.70 TT Totals 10,575 Difference to pay back is 7166. How does that match up?

The totals in TurboTax for your Form 1095-A should be exactly what's on your Form 1095-A since you enter the information.  

Review your entries to make sure that you entered your Form 1095-A correctly.