Insurance payments as retired Public Safety Officers entry doesn't add correctly on 1099 summary line 26d and causes an error that I can't correct...Help

I'm a retired Public Safety Officer, when working on my 1099-R I enter and amount of $2590 from box 5 for insurance paid.  After finishing my return and reviewing the program gives me an error in the 1099-R summary line 26d, it shows an amount of $5180 highlighted in blue and I am unable to correct it. 

The only way to correct 26d is to uncheck the box on my 1099-R to show that I'm not a Public Safety Officer which also increases my liability on taxes owed.