I live in NY and work in NJ. My NY state return is double counting my income - seemingly adding the box 16 amounts for NY and NJ (which are the same thing). Why is this?

Review your personal information that you've entered in TurboTax, which is needed to help ensure that you create the correct state tax returns. Also, delete the state returns and start over.  You shouldn't ‌be paying taxes on the same income in both states.

 

To delete your OH and IL tax returns, follow the steps below:

1. Open TurboTax and select State from the menu and Continue
2. On Status of your state returns screen select delete next to NJ and NY and confirm.

Refer to the TurboTax article How do I delete my state return in TurboTax Online?

 

Review your answers on the Personal profile screen. 

1. Select your name under Your info
2. Select Revisit
3. Scroll through the screens to ensure that you have the correct answers for your state of residence
4. Scroll down to Other State Income and select Edit
5. Check your answer for Did you make money in any other states? Answer Yes, and indicate that you made money in another state.

After you complete your federal tax return and you move to the State Taxes sections, both your non-resident state and resident state returns will be listed.  Prepare your non-resident  tax return first. Depending upon the state you live in, you may get a credit on your resident tax return if you paid taxes on you non-resident return.

 

For additional information, refer to the TurboTax Help articles Do I have to file tax returns in more than one state?,  Why would I have to file a nonresident state return? and How do I file a nonresident state return?