I am trying to file my 2023 taxes and when I log in it automatically pulls up info from 2022 and only gives me the option to “continue”. How do I change this?

Yes, whenever you start a 2023 tax return in TurboTax using the same account as last year, it always rolls forward your 2022 information so you don't have to re-enter every scrap of information from scratch. It's a timesaving feature that most people enjoy. 

If you would rather start with a completely blank slate and enter all of your information, you can sign out and start a new TurboTax with a new user ID.