Hi @smlambert10! The $10,200 Unemployment Income exemption was to reduce your taxable income by $10,200. It was not a credit for that dollar amount. The difference being that a credit is money that is given back to you dollar for dollar against tax owed, versus a reduction in income which your tax owed is then calculated from. The American Rescue Plan made it so the first $10,200 of Unemployment Income was tax-free, meaning that it reduced your income, and by proxy the total tax you owed. The IRS automatically made the adjustment for any additional refund from a reduction in tax owed, and it sounds like yours turned out to be $533.
Additional information can be found here: