I have gotten to: "Check This Entry: Form 1116 (COPY 1) Explanation Stm: Detailed explanation must be completed. Enter your explanation here to complete the required statement. It must show the other deduction items for line 3B column a."
It seems strange to me that I am being asked to explain a number that Turbo Tax calculated and entered. Have I confused the program or is this normal?
I have figured out that the number is the sum of: "Deductible part of Self Employment Tax" and "Self-employed Health Insurance Deduction" So is that what I should put in the explanation?
Yes you will enter that as an explanation in your return.
I just said "See Schedule 1 Part II" which is where this number seems to come from. Seems REALLY dumb that TT gives the user no help to explain a number that it came up with. Could be much improved imo.
Part I, line 3(b) is for "other deductions" and as such, it may include items that are not on the tax return, such as foreign deductions. The tax filer is asked to provide an explanation to insure that it is complete.
How do I open and view the form 1116 "Explanation Statement" to update my entries?
Thanks!
No, you don't need to explain your foreign tax paid, but you may specify if it was accrued or paid, and/ or if you want to take the credit or claim it on itemize deduction, if qualified,. The foreign tax paid is entered on Form 1116. You file Form 1116 if you are an individual, estate, or trust, and you paid or accrued certain foreign taxes to a foreign country or U.S. possession. To view your Form 1116 of Form 1040:
If the tax was solely for dividends from mutual funds (e.g. $605), would one typically choose the paid or the accrued method?
I'm having this same issue this year. How did you discover what the "other deduction" was that was being enter into line 3b column a? First year I've used TT. Doesn't seem like there's a way to see the actual form 1116 being generated, so I can't even see what the number is that I'm supposed to be explaining....
To see the Form 1116, TurboTax must be paid for so that you can download the PDF. To get to this section of your return, follow these steps:
For more information, see 2020 Instructions for Form 1116, page 16. Line 3b is only applicable to report other deductions that don't definitely relate to any specific type of income. For a taxpayer simply reporting foreign tax paid from Form 1099-DIV, it is uncommon for any adjustment to be required.
For more information, see: Filing IRS Form 1116 to Claim the Foreign Tax Credit - TurboTax Tax Tips & Videos
So dumb that TT still ask for this "explanation" for TY2021 while not explaining what kind of explanation it is for. Good thing there's google and this thread popped up.
But it seems TT automatically filled 3b (Other deduction (attach statement)) with the number from Schedule 1, Line 26 (Adjustments to income). It's TT that is doing this. I don't know know the reasoning, thus I cannot write a statement. What should the statement say about this Other deduction?
What I want to know is, why does the sum of the deductible portion of Self-Employment tax and the Self-Employed Health Insurance deduction -- both of which are shown clearly on the main part of the 1040 Form (Part II), show up in Turbotax's calculations for Schedule 1116 related to Foreign Tax Credit (thus generating the requirement for us to figure out where Turbotax is getting that number on Schedule 1116 from and then explain it to the IRS) -- when it never has in previous years? (I have had foreign tax credits before on my tax returns AND I have had both self-employment tax and self-employed health insurance for several years preceding 2020's tax return and never run into this explanation requirement in the "Federal Review" errors section.) And why TurboTax doesn't inform us where it is getting this line 3b information from in the Schedule 1116 worksheet so we have the information we need to explain it to the IRS (without stumbling across the number in looking at the forms TurboTax is generating -- or finding this question in the forums, thankfully).
Where and what do I say to explain form 1116 3b A asking for an explan
Explain what your non-Schedule A deductions on line 3b are, and why they're not definitely related to U.S. source income.
The instructions for Line 3b in the Instructions for Form 1116 are somewhat vague. They state:
Enter on line 3b any other deductions that don't definitely relate to any specific type of income (for example, the deduction for alimony paid from Schedule 1 (Form 1040), line 19a).
However, according to the instructions, lines 3a and 3b are used to report deductions that:
Line 3a is used for certain Schedule A Itemized Deductions, so line 3b would be used for any deductions you claim on your return that are not definitely related to your U.S. source income, and are not among those Schedule A deductions.
The example given is for alimony payments, which would be definitely related to U.S. source income. Similarly, just explain what your non-Schedule A deductions on line 3b are, and why they're not definitely related to U.S. source income.
If you don't know where, on your return, the line 3b deduction is coming from, you may need to go back through your entries in the federal interview to locate the amount. The amount wouldn't be from Schedule A medical expenses, general sales taxes or real estate taxes for your home, since those would be included on line 3a (see the instructions linked above).
once you pay for turbotax you can look at your 1040 or 1040SR (without filing yet).
Scroll down to your form 1116 and look at the amount on line 3b column a
then look at your 1040 (1040SR) and find that amount from above
in my case it was on the line that stated " Adjustments to income from Schedule 1, line 26"
so that was what I put for my explaination
I'm curious to know why the questions on this thread have not been authoritatively answered. TT seems to leave us high and dry after calculating a number and then letting us twist in the wind. The suggestion that an answer could be discerned after payment for TT has been made is vaguely blackmail-like?
Seriously, some sample explanations would be helpful.
Can you clarify what question you have or has not been answered? The post above tells someone how to view forms which you can only do after paying for TurboTax (in the Online version). You can preview Form 1040 without paying but if you want to see the details of Form 1116, you will need to pay your TurboTax fees first. But if you have a specific question, please ask here or start a new thread. @Onefish
In my case this was triggered by a "penalty for early withdrawal of savings". This was a little hard to track down since the entry for the penalty was not on any form from any financial institution where I paid foreign tax.
But all is good now. I simply entered "penalty for early withdrawal of savings".
The penalty was from cashing in a CD early, something I would not think of as affecting foreign tax paid.
I share everyone's frustration but take comfort in knowing that this is a turbotax thing, and not my mistake. Botton line is this doesn't have an effect on taxes owed. the line simply asks for an explanation of where the number comes from. so the honest answer is that it is a turbo tax program entry from the 1040 form adjustments to income