Why sign in to the Community?

  • Submit a question
  • Check your notifications
Sign in to the Community or Sign in to TurboTax and start working on your taxes
New Member
posted Jun 7, 2019 5:09:19 PM

Does IRS generally accept itsdeductable valuations

0 17 22467
1 Best answer
Level 3
Jun 7, 2019 5:09:21 PM

It depends what you mean by "accept."  By "accept," do you mean:

A, If I am audited for this specific thing, will it pass muster

or

B.  I used It's Deductible values on my taxes, will it trigger an audit?

I have been using It's Deductible for YEARS, ever since it was on a CD you had to get by mail.  I have never had the values I used trigger an audit.  But just to be sure, either print off or download a copy after you have entered a donation for a particular day to a particular organization.  This way, you have support for all the values used. 

Since I have never had an audit triggered for this, I cannot answer A, but I would presume it would pass muster.

17 Replies
Level 3
Jun 7, 2019 5:09:21 PM

It depends what you mean by "accept."  By "accept," do you mean:

A, If I am audited for this specific thing, will it pass muster

or

B.  I used It's Deductible values on my taxes, will it trigger an audit?

I have been using It's Deductible for YEARS, ever since it was on a CD you had to get by mail.  I have never had the values I used trigger an audit.  But just to be sure, either print off or download a copy after you have entered a donation for a particular day to a particular organization.  This way, you have support for all the values used. 

Since I have never had an audit triggered for this, I cannot answer A, but I would presume it would pass muster.

Level 3
Jun 7, 2019 5:09:22 PM

One additional thing.  Because values change, when you import into TurboTax, sometimes values will change. The values won't change on "custom" items.  If you want to ensure it doesn't change, you can use the values shown, but enter it as "custom."  If you use the standard values and enter as standard, sometimes it will change when imported into Turbo Tax.  

New Member
Jun 7, 2019 5:09:24 PM

An audit was triggered because of hard cover books. Be very careful of It's Deductible amounts.  I still use it but for some items I use custom because their amounts are too high.  Again an audit of all donations was triggered because of books! Luckily that's all they had a problem with.

New Member
Jun 7, 2019 5:09:25 PM

Not to be too nosy, but was it a lot of hardcover books? If it was triggered for just a few, I'll be worried.

Level 15
Jun 7, 2019 5:09:29 PM

Yes.

New Member
Jun 7, 2019 5:09:32 PM

I live in Arizona, and have used itsdeductible for several years.  The values are always changed a bit when the info is imported into my TurboTax file.  It's frustrating.

New Member
Jun 7, 2019 5:09:32 PM

I have been using this program since before it was obtained by Turbo Tax.  It is a great little program and I appreciate having the free program to record my donations and consolidate them in one place.  Remember you can always create a custom entry by adding it instead of using the value listed in the program.  Thanks Turbo Tax.

New Member
Jun 7, 2019 5:09:34 PM

I've been using It's Deductible with Turbo Tax for about 10 years and I have not been audited for my taxes or or anything I've donated or valued through It's Deductible. It's Deductible seems to use fair valuations for items, and I don't experience them as being too high. If anything, it's the opposite as I often donate designer clothing and footwear, and you can't really adjust for those other than the High or Low valuations it gives you unless you create a "Custom" amount (which I don't unless the item isn't on the list). 

Level 7
Jul 29, 2019 7:42:45 AM

They always have for me.  Since the values ID uses are based on eBay prices, they are pretty accurate.  I have used ID for years (with thousands of dollars of donations each year) and have never been audited.  I have put in hundreds of "add it" items for things not listed in ID, but I use eBay values for identical items in similar condition.  Just make sure you have a receipt from the charity.  I always print out my ID donation page and staple it to the receipt.

 

I hope this eases your mind a bit.

New Member
Feb 15, 2021 8:59:22 PM

I have never used ItsDeductible before - just to be safe I am using photo backup and online cost amounts for new items where I don't have a receipt. I also will have everything in an Excel file backup.

Expert Alumni
Feb 16, 2021 11:23:30 AM

@BrainyBoro Excellent suggestion! Some tax advisors suggest taking pictures of donated items. Records of online cost items are also helpful. The sales prices of properties similar to the donated property are often important in determining the fair market value of the donation.

 

It’s important to remember IRS audits are done by people. There are audit technique guides, but decisions can be subjective. If you disagree with an IRS examiner you can request to speak with their manager.

Level 2
Feb 23, 2021 7:34:08 AM

The hard cover books amount might seem high if you compare to the prices at Goodwill or at a library fundraiser sale.  But if you look at prices for similar items at most used book dealers, probably pretty much in line.  Perhaps an audit protection strategy would be to go to your local used book store, and take photos of the prices marked.

New Member
Apr 6, 2021 6:10:36 PM

Yes because TurboTax already cleared this with IRS for what is deductible and what's not and the price.

New Member
Feb 7, 2022 2:08:35 PM

We’ve NEVER had a problem. Have been using this program for years and have never been audited. That being said, we take pictures of everything we donate…(establishing item amounts & condition). When I had a great deal of items from clearing out  household items/decor; I also turned to e-bay for valuation of the same or very similar donation items (this helped me to feel I wasn’t overestimating any donation values.) Finally,  we are scrupulously accurate in all are tax matters-even to the point of filing thru a CPA, although are taxes aren’t really that complicated to warrant the extra professional level. -Maybe that helps? Who knows? We just do our best and if we happen to get audited, well, at least we can show we tried and there weren’t any shenanigans involved. Good Luck!

New Member
Feb 7, 2022 2:10:40 PM

Not me. I’ve donated TONS of hardcover books, textbooks and paperbacks. Never had a problem!

New Member
Apr 10, 2022 7:45:37 AM

It is a good idea to go to one time to Goodwill or a thrift shop to familiarize yourself with prices.  At a Goodwill in NC, all shirts (many almost new or new) are $4.50, good framed pictures or paintings 24" X 36" go for $20, soft cover books are $1, and hard cover books are $1.50.  If picture frames are damaged, the price is about a third off. 

Level 1
Apr 28, 2022 12:44:22 PM

I have been audited. They questioned the quantity not the Itsdeductable value. Fortunately someone told me to take pictures. I have a photo documentation that details the location, date & time of the photos