If I go into Edit/Add, they are both properly listed with the right amounts. But in the "Your Income" summary page, only the income from the first one is listed. I don't understand why they're both not showing up.
Both IRS form 1099-MISC's may be found under Income from Form 1099-MISC. Click Edit / Add to the right to view the forms.
The entry reported in box 3 will be reported as other income and may be found on
The entry reported in box 6 for medical payments is to be reported as a self-employment activity and TurboTax wants you to complete the description of the self-employment activity. See needs review and Review to the right of Self-employment income and expenses.
Reporting the medical payments as a self-employment activity will allow you to enter expenses against the income and offset the income. The self-employment activity will be reported on Schedule C Profit or Loss From Business.