pk
Level 15
Level 15

Deductions & credits

@p_r_s , having gone through  the discussion with @DaveF1006 , I would like to point out the following:

  For US tax Purposes:

(a)   Since you were admitted to the USA on L visa  on Feb. 3rd 2022, you would have started  counting days present  from the first full day thereafter -- so probably from the 4th of Feb ( depending on when you actually arrived , but let us assume Feb 4th. for this discussion.  Thus you would have passed  Substantial Presence Test  early in August of 2022. Hence you would be a Resident for Tax purposes for the year 2022.   Your start of the year  would be the first full day you were in the USA for any purposes.  Thus you would be resident for tax purposes  Feb 4th. through 12/31/2022.

(b)  Since  your Tax-home is USA ,  your world income from  the  Residency start date  on-wards would be subject to US taxes.  Therefore  your US earnings  Feb 4th. on wards is  US sourced  income and taxable by US. Furthermore, because your tax home is US for the period, the income is  not foreign. Any earlier  income i.e. prior to entering the USA is foreign income , foreign  tax home, you had no presence in the USA and hence not within the ambit of US tax laws.

(c) While I agree with the procedure for claiming foreign tax credit  for any amounts taxed by both jurisdiction , I do not find any merit to the claim that you need to include  any income from India  for the month of Jan 2022  ( tax home, residency, work-place  etc. ). Please do not do this as it will complicate things further.

 

For INDIA purposes

(d)  While the tax year in India was 04/01/2021 through 03/31/2022, your residency changed  on 02/04/2022 ; your "new " employer has a locus in USA and therefore an US entity, and while the treaty article you quoted is a bit confusing, generally safer to give primacy to one residency, I think India  can claim only your  income 04/01/2021 through 02/03/2022.

(e) I don't know the exact procedure  to amend a return in India ,( I know it is possible and done often by businesses ) perhaps  it is best that you amend your return filed in India  I say this because to try to get foreign tax credit to avoid / ameliorate  double taxation  for the  months  Feb & March 2022, you would have to re-source  the US incomes for those months  as foreign and while quite doable, is more complicated and may not survive a challenge.

 

Does this make sense  ?

Is there more I can do for you ?

 

pk,