"If I simply withhold the funds from my check it goes into pre-tax as current year contributions to the 401k.. If I report part of that on my 8915-F as paid back, I would also have to reduce the amount in 12b code D on my W-2, I believe. This doesn't feel right, so I'm still not sure how to handle still." It doesn't feel right because it is not right ... you cannot repay the distribution this way.
