You are correct, that is not right.
Did you enter all of your income from work as taxable on your NY return? If you mistakenly told TurboTax to remove all of your income from your NY return, it would then result in a refund of your taxes withheld. Walk back through your NY return and be sure that all of the income that you earned at work is included in your NY taxable income.
Did you file NY first as your nonresident return or PA first or did you reverse the order? Be sure you file NY first and then you will claim a credit for taxes paid to NY on your PA return. You do not want to claim a credit for taxes paid on your NY return, only on your PA return.
**Say "Thanks" by clicking the thumb icon in a post
**Mark the post that answers your question by clicking on "Mark as Best Answer"
