After you file

@CatinaT1 

You are not answering the original problem.  We are just trying to create the tax amendment from a return that has been filed and refunded has been granted.  Just use turbotax to create a new tax amendment for 2022 tax and open the already filed tax return. Then the indicator shows some number like $44 for my case.  It should start out at $0.   

 

How to get to first to show $0.  You also stated that it does not always show $0. But then I add the changes to the amendment and the final refund indicator is the difference I supposed to pay + the initial $44.  How I know? I am trying to amend for a excess roth contribution and penalty of $360 I expect.  After entering this excess contribution, the refund indicator shows -$316.  

 

How to fix this?