Did you file the NY extension at all ? NY doesn't "piggyback" off the federal ... they require their own form to be filed and you had to initiate this in the state's interview section.
How do I request an extension for my state if I used TurboTax Easy Extension?
https://ttlc.intuit.com/questions/1899449
New York (NY)
You can e-file an extension by April 18 at this dedicated TurboTax link. You can also print an extension with TurboTax that you mail in. Start your NY return, if you haven't already done so, and look for the extension question. If you don't see it, step through your NY return again from the beginning. The state of New York will not accept a copy of federal Form 4868 in place of Form IT-370.
The extension gives you until October 15 to file. If you owe, submit payment by April 18 to avoid penalties and interest, either by paying with your extension or by going to their Online Services site.
