After you file

Again "out of whack"  is hard to diagnose in a public forum ... the program does math calculations very well 99.9% of the time ... the variable would be the user making an input error 99.9% of the time or just not understanding the situation.   

 

So put the returns side by side ...  what increased the taxes?   Were you self employed that year ?  Did you have to pay back some or all of the Obamacare credit ?   Was it a simply data entry error on the W-2 for the income or withholding ?   And why didn't you question this 2 years ago?