Yes it should all be on the same W2. The federal tax withholding you had taken out is included in W2 box 2 with your regular withholding. The tax withholding may be less than the $1834.10 because some would be for SS & Medicare tax. Look at your paystubs. Ask your employer if you don't understand your W2.
You get a credit for all the box 2 withholding on 1040 line 25a.
