Wow! If your analysis is correct, that makes me wonder too. At this point I don't know what to say.
I always filed my 2555 using the 'bonefide resident" test. Thanks for your insight with this. I'm going to print out your comments and run them by with TurboTax this Friday when I have a call. I'll post here the follow up.
So as I understand it. I shouldn't be receiving any refund, and I did the right when faxing to the IRS to delete my foreign withholding from line 16 and make it 0.0 which will give me a 0.0 refund.
I'll also confirm with TurboTax on the call that I should also be filling out form 1116 in the future and if TurboTax Online will provide form 1116 next year.
Thanks so much for your insight and comments. Again. I'll post back here what TurboTax said. Hopefully it will be a "simple" confirmation of what you have already explained.
