Retirement tax questions

I  should have mentioned that I have 4 Roth IRA's that I opened over 5 years ago.  Meaning all 4 are over 5 year old  or older.   At 4 different banks / brokerages.  One only has about $500.00 the rest have more.

I'm 65 years old.

 

1. I though the ROTH IRA 5 year rule was based on your oldest ROTH IRA, not any subsequent ROTH IRA's opened after your initial ROTH IRA.  Yes you would have to be 59 1/2 to withdraw without penalty.  But subsequent ROTH IRA's would follow the original 1st IRA clock in terms of the 5 year rule.

 

2. Now I want to convert my 457 money to a Roth IRA.  I was told by the 457 administrators that, by doing this I would be starting a new 5 year rule on this money.  Meaning I would have to wait 5 years to withdraw without the 10% penalty.  No mention of the conversion penalty.  

 

These IRA's can get too deep with rules..

 

Appreciate everyone's input and previous reply's.

 

Have a good weekend.

 

 

 

 

But based on that 457 money, If I understood correctly I