So far I count 28 messages on this thread with exactly the same complaint about inaccurate calculations by Turbo Tax. If 28 smart people and unknown others who haven't taken the trouble to write in make the same "error" I think the vote is against Turbo Tax and they should admit that there is some glitch in that question with strange default to checking the "yes" box for one or the other spouse and they should admit (and fix) the error and make good on their accuracy guarantee.
I work in an industry where errors can have fatal consequences and I have often argued that when multiple smart people make the same error the problem lies with systems and procedures, not with individual workers.
