@DanaB27 so I just clicked on the continue button and in the next step or 2 it asked what year the 1099-R form was for, so I selected 2025. Still unsure about the year it's taxable, since after I selected "Code P" it didn't mention it would be taxable in 2024. I assume it just is automatically, even though the code shows 2023? As I continued on it also came to the screen where I could enter the "Corrective distributions made before the due date of the return" where I entered the $4.45 earnings. The only other thing I wasn't expecting was it asked to describe the reason for the IRA return or something like that, so I just explained that before filing our taxes I realized I had contributed over the $8,000 limit to our Roth IRA, so that is why we had the $75 removed plus the attributable earnings. Hopefully that will suffice.
Again, I can't thank you enough for all the help you've given me on this matter. It appears everything is oK with our tax return. It didn't find any errors, at least! If you notice anything wrong with the screenshot I uploaded in my previous reply, or anything I've mentioned above, please let me know. I will probably wait until tomorrow to file the taxes.
