Well, another thought occurs to me. You might (if your HSA custodian has a sense of humor) tell the HSA custodian that the $715 was a mistaken distribution. The withdrawal of mistaken contributions was really supposed to be $537.
If the HSA custodian accepts this (they don't have to), they will expect you to send you a check for the $715 that they sent you, and then they would send you $537 back for the correct withdrawal. This would bring your tax return into conformity with your bank balance (since TurboTax handled the actual and correct withdrawal).
Otherwise the two 1099-SAs may be necessary...but work on the HSA custodian first to see if they will let you "fix" the withdrawal for excess contributions.
**Say "Thanks" by clicking the thumb icon in a post
**Mark the post that answers your question by clicking on "Mark as Best Answer"
