Retirement tax questions

Opus 17,

I appreciate your research, but I don't understand what do you mean by"No. Please stop. " I did not make things complicated.  I understand the pay stubs.  I am cleared now.  I have no questions about it.   I described  it in my last post was because you/someone said "we are not working with the facts" The w2 and the scholarship amounts are from the pay stubs. 

On the pay stub, it indicated "Stipend - PA tax exempt." W-2 $$$ is the Stipend $$$ amount.

I read your long research.  The stipend qualifies for PA-tax exempt.  But it's complicated where it wants you to show "blablabla."

 

School knows the best.  If they say it's tax exempt, it's tax exempt.  We just follow the school's direction.  

 

Thank you again!