Retirement tax questions

You still have to file 2023 Form 5329 showing the excess on Line 18

and the resolution on Line 24 with the Box checked,

as documented by your 2023 1099-Rs.

 

If your amended 2022 Form 5329 doesn't have the excess on Line 24, you filed incorrectly.

But it must be non-zero to give you a 2022 penalty which you say you paid.

@gjgogol