Retirement tax questions

@dgelineau I wish I could say yes but I can't. I am in the process of starting my taxes over again with a local CPA. As you can see from the thread non of the TT "experts" knew the answer since they were all different. One would mean I owed nothing, one meant I owed thousands and one way meant I would get back over $20,000. Insane that not one of them knew the answer.